Haven't you noticed how many ultra-famous composers have works that are nowadays nearly never performed live and can be hardly obtained recorded?

For example:

Tchaikovsky: Piano Concertos Nos. 2 and 3; seems that people lack interest for those works after hearing the super famous No.1
Liszt: All of his choral and religious works
Dvorak: All of his symphonies before the 7th
Saint-Saens: Christmas Oratorio, Op.12
Grieg: Symphony in C minor
Wagner: Symphony in C major

...just to start the list.

Why does this happen, if many of these pieces also contain catchy melodies and are written with their composers usual mastery?

I don't really think people evade the 2nd concerto, it has been recorded many times (Postnikova, Richter, Gilels, Pletnev, Telerman, Donohoe...); of course, not as many as the first concerto.
But I think this actually applies to the Andante and Allegro, the Concert Fantasy, and the Piano sonata in c sharp minor.


My interest on this work sticks to the Prelude, I don't really like the rest of it. But there's more Saint-Saens I like more, like the 3rd piano concerto and the second violin concerto. (And his left hand etudes... but they are etudes, perhaps that's why they are not recorded frequently)


Sibelius: even though his violin concerto is part if the standard repertoire, his other works for violin and orchestra (Serenade, Humoresques, etc) are just not recorded/played by anyone. Well... Rosand and Tetzlaff, but that's not enough.

Unplayed and almost unknown: The chamber instrumental works of:
Saint-Saëns - Sibelius except Voces Intimae - Schubert all his SQ before
the 14th - Dvorak all his SQ before the "american" - Mozart all his early
SQ - Strauss all his chamber - Suk all his chamber - Mendelssohn, except
the octet how many other chamber works are played regulary?
And I can go on and on...

Good thread.

Handel: The Choice of Hercules, Almira
Haydn: His piano trios.

Mendelssohn - his violin concerto for string orchestra.

Beethoven

His songs (I've never heard them)

String Trios

Choral Fantasy for Piano and Orchestra (compared to his other piano works)

If there is such a thing as an underrated work by Beethoven, it may be his "Choral Fantasy". It's magnificent!

I totally agree!! I keep listening to it these days... I don't see how people say it's simply a curiosity.

More about unheard Beethoven compositions.

Opus67, thanks for the link!

Songs are probably the least performed pieces by any author that is not especially famous for them (i.e. Schubert, Schumann, Brahms).

Who ever records songs of Delius & fellow Englishmen, the Nordic composers, Liszt, Debussy, Beethoven as mentioned etc. ?

- The 6th is often played in the Czech Republic -

But #'s 1-5 are not. The simple reason for this is that there is a dramatic shift in style between #'s 1-5 and #'s 6-9. The early ones are written in a Wagnerian-Lisztian vein and contain very little of the Czech national flavour that are prevalent in the later ones.

__________________
The Sibelius Forum
My New Website
New ZSO Website

I think the 6th is still a german experiment.

Piano concerto in c minor by Gabriel Pierné is Camille Saint-Saens' least known piano concerto.

Oh boy! Not another debate on the "true genius" of a composer.

I was thinking more in a debate about copycats.

Seems to me that "nearly-forgotten" depends so much on where you're standing. I would never have thought Bizet's symphony was anything but an overplayed warhorse. But that's because the radio station in Sacramento where I grew up played it all the time. I heard it before I'd heard any music from Carmen. And I've known, and loved all of Dvorak's symphonies for as long as I can remember. (I prefer five and six, though I'm pretty sure eight is his best. I would have picked seven and nine as the least Czech-sounding, but I'd better defer to Kurkikohtaus on this!)

Things go in and out of "favor." And so often there seems to be no logic in it but caprice. Why has there never been but one recording of Piston's delightful Incredible Flutist ballet? Roberto Gerhard, well in the running for most underappreciated great composer of the twentieth century, gets a brief flurry of hard to get lps and then a brief flurry of cds. One good thing, the lps seem easier to find nowadays than back in the day.

In fact, on this thread, I'd be tempted to say every piece by Gerhard is "nearly-forgotten." But Gerhard is only nearly famous.