Thread: My Symphony Three

If billy would use even half of that energy for studying. theory and his favorite. symphonye
s by his favorite composers
i bet that he would. improve fast.

By the way, I'm assuming some people thought that what I said about "comedic genius" was intended as an insult. It wasn't; I greatly prize humour in music. I thought the first movement of the 10th was funny, I enjoyed it! The rest, not so much, but Billy doesn't seem to care what we think, if anything I think he's taking the considerable amount of talk about his music, good or bad, as a compliment.

Originally Posted by BurningDesire

Good point about single movement works. About "light-weight" symphonies, you wouldn't say that something not being really heavy makes it less good, would you?

No, and I didn't.

Originally Posted by Delicious Manager

Now I think you're just a troll. I believe (as has been suggested before in this thread) that you are just recording random 'improvisations' on your keyboard. There is no other way you could be churning out so much audio drivel so quickly. The 'music' has no worth whatsoever. I think you know this and you're just trying to wind us up.

Maybe you should find a new hobby?

I suspect that you are correct in that Billy just records these from a midi keyboard to a sequencer. A half-hour symphony takes him a half-hour to compose. No score is produced and no real thought goes into the development aside from the whims of the moment.

Originally Posted by Couchie

I suspect that you are correct in that Billy just records these from a midi keyboard to a sequencer. A half-hour symphony takes him a half-hour to compose. No score is produced and no real thought goes into the development aside from the whims of the moment.

It's like free improvised jazz except this guy is trying to do it with a full midi orchestra and doesn't really know enough theory.

Originally Posted by ComposerOfAvantGarde

It's like free improvised jazz except this guy is trying to do it with a full midi orchestra and doesn't really know enough theory.

Nothing against improvisation, but even Mozart worked in a series of sketches and drafts before attempting to put together a symphony.

It should be "My Symphony Tree".

Classical Symphony Eighteen:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sG2aiM3DY2A

Originally Posted by Billy

Classical Symphony Eighteen:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sG2aiM3DY2A

Seriously though, Billy, you will have read what we have said about your music, and I think for the best part we have tried to be honest with you, agree? You obviously haven't taken any notice, which is your prerogative of course, so can I ask why do you keep posting these 'symphonies' when they sound all the same?

Originally Posted by beetzart

Seriously though, Billy, you will have read what we have said about your music, and I think for the best part we have tried to be honest with you, agree? You obviously haven't taken any notice, which is your prerogative of course, so can I ask why do you keep posting these 'symphonies' when they sound all the same?

I second that motion!

If this continues for more than a week or so, Billhelmina will be up to 'classical symphony' No 63 by the time we all shoot ourselves.

Originally Posted by Delicious Manager

If this continues for more than a week or so, Billhelmina will be up to 'classical symphony' No 63 by the time we all shoot ourselves.

What's the problem? Nobody is forced to listen to the stuff.

Classical Symphony Nineteen:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7pdUmhk5GM

Good god. Check out these lyrics

I am a black woman in heaven.
I am a black woman in heaven.
Lord is my Lord and Savior.
I am a black woman in heaven.

I actually really like that song.