Classical Music Forum banner

Happy composers club?

7K views 18 replies 8 participants last post by  marie 
#1 ·
It is a well known fact that the greatest masterpieces have been composed as a result of distress and unhappiness. Almost all great composers had (big) problems of some kind: Beethoven was getting deaf, Mahler was tormented, Mozart was discontent, etc. Not to mention that almost all great composers were poor or facing day-to-day material problems.

Until now, I knew of only one exception to that rule: Mendelssohn. Son of wealthy bankers, he had no material problems. His attachment to his sister, and her premature loss did eventually kill him; but the inspiration in his music is all happiness. In the most troubled romantic times, he wrote an overture named "Calm Sea and Happy Voyage" :) ... that says it all!

A few days ago, I found a CD with piano works of French / German Louis Theodore Gouvy (1819-1898) - piano music for four hands by Yaara Tal & Andreas Groethuysen (Sony). What a gem! This is very highly inspired music! Having researched a bit more about that hitherto unknown composer, I learnt that he wrote 9 symphonies (none of which have ever been recorded???) and and plenty of other works. Gouvy, like Mendelssohn, had no material problems, and lead a worry-free life, sponsored by his wealthy family.

So, the club of happy composers has only 2 members?
 
See less See more
#5 ·
Mozart was discontent, etc. Not to mention that almost all great composers were poor or facing day-to-day material problems.
Mozart's was rarely (if ever) remotely poor. And he wasn't discontent more than any person. Everyone is discontent at some points in there life.

Bach? His inspiration was God - I believe he was content enough..
He believe his inspiration was God. ;)
 
G
#6 ·
It is an oft repeated fact, but facts are either true or false. This one happens to be false.

Many people are miserable, as Yagan has already said, Mozart et cetera no more or less than anyone else. The idea that the wellspring of true inspiration is suffering is a pernicious one, methinks. Composers are people who are sometimes sad and sometimes happy, just like all the rest of us. All the ones I know, even when they're complaining about this or that lack of money or audience, seem pretty happy for the most part.

And their works are perfectly fine.
 
#7 ·
Valid points have been made here.

I agree that Bach's music does reflect some kind of happiness. Yet: 10 of his children and his first wife died. He wrote cantatas like "Christ lag in Todesbanden" ("Christ lay in death's bonds"), "Wir müssen durch viel Trübsal" ("We suffer through much affliction"), aria "Ich freue mich auf meinen Tod" ("I look forward to death"). So happiness... yes... but rather sad happiness... and, of course breathtakingly beautiful because of that.

Haydn's music is all joy and happy mischief indeed. But Haydn's father was a wheelwright and Joseph had to work hard to make a living. He was a servant to the Esterhazys; not born wealthy himself.

I must admit I know less about Aaron Copland but, although his parents were doing well, they were new immigrants; so he was certainly brought up in more unstable conditions than Mendelssohn and Gouvy.

What made me start this thread is the analogy between Mendelssohn and Gouvy. I suppose that their relatively worry-free lives, sponsored by their established wealthy families, lead them to write a very peculiar type of music. Having myself had a displaced, broken and rather poor family, I find that their music has a form of serenity which I crave for.
 
#8 ·
What made me start this thread is the analogy between Mendelssohn and Gouvy. I suppose that their relatively worry-free lives, sponsored by their established wealthy families, lead them to write a very peculiar type of music. Having myself had a displaced, broken and rather poor family, I find that their music has a form of serenity which I crave for.
But I thought that we are talking about "happy composers club" and not "wealthy composers club". I saw some videos with Copland and he seemed to be mellow and satisfied man. He can compose, he wasn't poor and he had his audience admiring him. On the other hand, everbody has his own problems as Mendelssohn sure had.

Finally, Chopin in Paris wasn't poor anyway...and I wouldn't qualify him as happy composer.
 
#9 ·
Interesting discussion. Thank you for starting the thread!

I suppose that Mozart was feeling good when he composed happy music and that he was feeling down when he wrote sad/angry music. I find it somewhat difficult to imagine that you could compose happy music when you cannot really feel that way. I don't know…... You could perhaps fake your feeling to some extent. But when you put your soul into your music, I would think that your true Self emerges.
 
#10 ·
[q] I find it somewhat difficult to imagine that you could compose happy music when you cannot really feel that way.[/q]He wrote Eine Kleine shortly after one of his parents died. And Sturm und Drang was getting popular in that era, so there is no need for emotional interference.
 
#11 ·
This is a tough question because of the almost Lockean distinction between composer's wealth, music, etc. ("secondary qualities") and his state of mind ("primary qualities"). With that said, the only composers I can think of that were "truly happy" are modern composers, as it's easier to observe their happiness directly (through interviews, performances, etc). I would cite John Cage as a prime example (he was known for his laugh) and, and I think, Aaron Copland as a lesser example.
 
#14 ·
I think that I should make a distinction between having a happy mood (temporal emotions) and being a happy person. While the former could be affected by the external environment and stressors, the latter is more to do with the internal personal trait.

After I learned from another poster that Mozart composed his Eine Kleine shortly after one of his parents died, I have been thinking what made him to compose such a heavenly comfortable music.

Renoir kept painting happy pictures whatever his external circumstances were. I feel that Renoir would have been a person who had an internal happiness.

We often discover sublime beauty even when we are facing a very stressful situation. When I am absorbed in that beauty, I am not thinking about the stress. As long as I feel connected with that beauty, I feel internally happy. But if I am too stressed out, perhaps I wouldn't be able to discover that beauty in the first place.
 
#18 ·
Health problems were common in the 19th century and nobody was immune from them. Many of the great composers of that era died relatively young. As Elliot Carter enters his 100th year I don't know anything about his state of happiness but would guess he is at least somewhat satisfied. Leonard Bernstein always seemed pretty happy to me. Many great composers experienced misery but by no means all of them did.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top