Classical Music Forum banner

Game (semi-final 2): twofer concertos

2K views 44 replies 9 participants last post by  Art Rock 
#1 ·
Welcome to the second semi-final of the twofer concertos game. We have nominated 34 combinations, who will now be pitted against eachother in two semi-finals and a final.

Voting Rules:

1. You may vote once daily (your calendar day).

2. To vote, please:
- copy/paste the previous post
- remove the (+x) by the previous poster
- add your votes and include your own (+x) after them
- after posting, please check whether someone else has posted just before you
- if so, adjust your post accordingly
- please do not bold the compositions you vote for, please do not use different colours
- if you want, you can bold the composition reaching the finish line (60)
- please do not delete the reminder statement about halfway the compositions list

3. When you vote, you will have 10 upward points to use as you wish except that no work may receive more than 3 points.

4. The Half-Time Adjustment is not in effect.

5. The round ends with the first twofer to collect 60 points.

At the end of the round, the top eight twofers will move to the final (I'll use a tiebreaker if required - the last time there was a difference between the twofers involved).

The full list of the two semi-finals can be found here.
 
See less See more
#27 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 22 (+3)
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 14
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 38 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 15
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 18
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 8
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 6

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 28
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 8
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 29 (+2)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 19

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 20 (+2)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 8
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 13
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 10
 
#28 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 22
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17 (+3)
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 38
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 15
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 18
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 8
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 6

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 28
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9 (+1)
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 29
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 19

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 23 (+3)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11 (+3)
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 13
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 10
 
#29 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 25 (+3)
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 38
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 16 (+1)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 21 (+3)
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 11 (+3)
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 6

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 28
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 29
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 19

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 23
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 13
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 10
 
#30 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 25
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 41 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 17 (+1)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 21
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 11
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 6

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 31 (+3)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 32 (+3)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 19

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 23
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 13
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 10
 
#31 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 25
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 44 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 17
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 21
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 11
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 6

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 32 (+1)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 32
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 19

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 23
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16 (+3)
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13 (+3)
 
#32 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 25
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 44
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 17
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 24 (+3)
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 11
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9 (+3)

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 33 (+1)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 32
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 22 (+3)

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 23
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#33 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 28 (+3)
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 47 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 17
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 24
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 11
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 33
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 34 (+2)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 22

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 25 (+2)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#34 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 28
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 17
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 48 (+1)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 20 (+3)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 24
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14 (+3)
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 33
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 37 (+3)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 22

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 25
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 11
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#35 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 28
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 20 (+3)
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 49 (+1)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 20
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 24
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 33
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 37
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 22

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 28 (+3)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14 (+3)
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#36 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 28
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 20
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 52 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 21 (+1)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 24
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 36 (+3)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 40 (+3)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 22

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 28
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#37 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31 (+3)
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 23 (+3)
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 52
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 21
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 24
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 38 (+2)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 9
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 40
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 24 (+2)

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 28
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#38 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 23
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 52
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 21
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 27 (+3)
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 9

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 38
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 11 (+2)
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 40
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 26 (+2)

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 31 (+3)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 16
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#39 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 23
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 52
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 21
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 30 (+3)
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 11 (+2)

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 38
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 11
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 40
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 29 (+3)

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 31
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 18 (+2)
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 13
 
#40 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 23
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 55 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 2

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 21
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 30
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 14
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 11

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 41 (+3)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 11
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 40
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 29

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 31
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 21 (+3)
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 14 (+1)
 
#41 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 23
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 55
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 3 (+1)

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 24 (+3)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 30
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 17 (+3)
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 11

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 41
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 11
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 43 (+3)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 29

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 31
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 21
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 14
 
#42 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 25 (+2)
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 55
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 3

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 24
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 30
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 17
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 11

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 41
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 11
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 43
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 29

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 34 (+3)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14 (+3)
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 78 - (+2)
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 14
 
#43 ·
Corrections made to Shostakovich information given by Roger Knox above...

Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 25
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 58 (+3)
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 3

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 25 (+1)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 30
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 17
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 11

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 44 (+3)
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 11
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 46 (+3)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 29

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 34
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 23
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 14
 
#44 ·
Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043 - 31
Bartók - Violin no. 2 / Piano no. 3 - 25
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2 - 60 (+2) :trp:
Dohnányi - Piano no.1 / Piano no. 2 - 4 (+1)

Dvořák - Cello / Violin - 26 (+1)
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet - 30
Khachaturian - Piano / Violin - 17
Mendelssohn - Piano no. 1 / Violin - 11

Gentle reminder: you have 10 points, no twofer may receive more than 3 points.

Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major - 44
Poulenc - Organ in G minor / Piano in C-sharp minor - 13 (+2)
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor - 48 (+2)
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major - 29

Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major - 36 (+2)
Sallinen - Violin / Cello - 2
Scharwenka, FX - Piano no. 1/ Piano no. 4 - 14
Shostakovich - Cello no. 1, op. 107/ Violin no. 1, op. 77 - 23
Weinberg - Cello, op. 43/Violin, op. 67 - 14
 
#45 · (Edited)
And that's that. Moving to the final:

Bach, JS - Harpsichord BWV 1052 / Two Violins BWV 1043
Brahms - Piano no. 1 / Piano no. 2
Dvořák - Cello / Violin
Finzi - Cello / Clarinet
Mozart - Piano no. 23 in A major / Clarinet in A major
Rachmaninoff - Piano no. 2 in C minor / Piano no. 3 in D minor
Ravel - Piano in G major / Piano for the Left Hand in D major
Röntgen - Violin no. 1 in A minor/ Piano no. 4 in F Major

The final will start within 12 hours.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top