I usual prefer organ or clavichord in JSB's keyboard music and see no reason to choose between piano and harpsichord or any of the four, they bring different depths to the enrich music.
The music is wonderfully versatile and sounds good on all of them, but I have a slight preference for harpsichord, especially for the faster pieces such as the Italian Concerto.
Seriously, I prefer to listen to the keyboard music on piano, though I should explore more of the harpsichord recordings of his works. I have a piano bias, I admit it!
I remember reading a newspaper article by the late Douglas Adams who, as he wrote, was listening to some midi files of (I think) The Well-Tempered Clavier on his laptop. He reflected that Bach's music sounds wonderful no matter which instrument(s) are playing it. I'd go along with that; among my favourite Bach recordings is that of the Art of Fugue played by the New Century Saxophone Quartet, and it's wonderful.
I enjoy the concertos with the original harpsichord, but I personally cannot listen to solo harpsichord music for any length of time. So his solo keyboard works, I'll take the piano.
I really do not care other than I like and want both.
A fine performance is a fine performance, and all the innate dynamics the various ranges inherent to the harpsichord (Which are very much a part of 'how to play Bach') can be transliterated in a performance on a piano -- without at all trying to achieve or mimic 'harpsichord.'
Any pianist playing earlier literature written for earlier period pianos runs into the same thing re: innate dynamic through the various ranges of the instrument and how the composers worked with that, and that too can be rendered on a modern piano.
For the concertos, I definitely prefer harpsichord - to me this feels completely right.
For the solo keyboard, I honestly enjoy listening to either. If I had to take one group of Bach keyboard recordings though, it would be the organ works!
The strange thing is Bach's keyboard music sounds as though it was composed for the piano, the cross-over is amazing. The concertos still seem better on the harpsichord but works like the WTC seem to have a greater emotional depth on the piano. I always fine the Chromatic Fantasy & Fugue only works best on the harpsichord, and never fails to astound.
well I think WTC played on piano sounds plain weird.. As is the case with most other Bach keyboard works. The piano makes the bass lines muddy and pianists play them soft like a "baroque angel" () on the modern piano, which is probably not Bach actually would have wanted them played.
There are so many good piano and harpsichord records of the Goldbergs and WTC that it's hard to choose. In the AoF, the partitas and the suites I'm less certain, my feeling is that harpsichordists have so far made the most imaginative recordings (especially in AoF the English Suites) but I may be wrong. I definitely prefer recordings of the acompanied viol and violin sonatas with harpsichord. Same for the concertos. I've never heard Musical Offering with a piano.
I like both but for certain works such as the '48', AoF and Goldbergs I favour harpsichord. However, I'm thinking of getting Richter's '48' on RCA - any fans here?
I found Richter's recording has certain rawness about it and he certainly isn't short on commitment, but out of many, many versions (excepting Edwin Fisher's unique historic account) I have found the most satisfying to be Evgeni Koroliov - I got the 4 CD set on Tacet.
I'm glad I started this poll, because I used to think everybody liked Bach on piano - but no, it's not that bad!
I think classical and romantic composers exploit the piano very well, because, well, they were composing on it. Bach's music sounds divine on the harpsichord, and merely listenable on piano, IMHO.
Yes. Bach's music sounds best on the instruments he created it for. Nothing quite like a great harpsichord performance of the WTC, Goldberg Variations, Keyboard Partitas, French and English Suites and Toccatas.
I've heard a lot of Bach on the piano and can't name any that I would prefer over Trevor Pinnock or Gustav Leonhardt.
Hell, Bach's music sounds great on just about any instrument. For the Goldbergs, I have recordings on harpsichord (several - Suzuki, Pinnock, Gilbert), piano (Gould, Perahia, Koroliov), organ (Guillou), and viol ensemble (Fretwork). I have also heard it on harp. While I don't enjoy all equally, all made a credible showing of themselves. One of my favorite recordings of the Art of Fugue is by a saxophone quartet. I enjoy the Hanssler Edition of the "48" played on a variety of keyboard instruments, including organ. I enjoy listening to these works on the original instrument for which they were composed, but I also like seeing just how versatile Bach's works can be. Yet another testimony to me of the man's genius.
My preference is for the harpsichord, but I have hundreds of piano discs of Bach's solo keyboard music that I listen to regularly. At the top of the list are Gould, Koroliov, Woodward, Tureck and a few others.
For me, the harpsichord just sounds like the perfect instrument for Bach's solo keyboard music. It also helps that I never tire of listening to the harpsichord. When I listen to Bach on piano for a few hours, I feel the need for a cleansing. "Sharp" is unfortunately not a quality I find on the piano.
Concerning chamber music such as the Sonatas for Keyboard and Violin, it's harpsichord all the way. The piano ruins it for me.
I voted for piano, but I cannot imagine a piano in the 5th Brandenburg Concerto solo, and I think a piano would sound too loud in those Brandenburg Concertos that have harpsichord parts (all except #3?)
For me, I don't really really care if Bach is played on a piano or harpsichord. But for some pieces, like the Goldberg Concertos, French Suites, Fugues, etc, I perfer to listen to them played on a piano but for the Italian Concerto, Keyboard Concertos and some lesser known pieces, I prefer harpsichord.
For any other Baroque composer (Handel, Scarlatti), I will almost always pick a harpsichord recording over a piano recording.
I love HIP recordings, but honestly I have far more great recordings of Bach's music on piano: Gould, Schiff, Perahia, Hewitt, Edwin Fischer, Rosalyn Tureck, Sviatoslav Richter, etc... As DrMike suggested, Bach sounds great on a vast array of instruments. I have the Goldberg Variations and the Art of Fugue performed on harp, string quartet, recorder ensemble, chamber orchestra, organ, clavichord, etc... Personally I have no use for purists and dogma when it comes to music.
I think the harpsichord has a more articulate, forward sound than the piano. This works better with contrapuntal works, allowing the performer to concentrate on the structural line. The piano introduces problems of dynamics and coloring that can complicate things. No to mention how the single keyboard can make performance much more difficult for certain pieces that were written with a double-keyboard harpsichord in mind. I always prefer the harpsichord with ANY baroque composer.
I'm a little biased, though. I've always loved the rich and virtuosic nature of the harpsichord's technique. I know that a piano can also produce oodles of virtuosity. but the harpsichord has a special virtuosic sound when played right. While the piano has a sound that is like a beam of light being adjusted by a shade, the harpsichord is like a pure beam without adjustment; this sharp and penetrating feel that gives the baroque it's trademark sound.
For the concerti, harpsichord no doubt. They sound like they were written for the harpsichord and they work much better with it, in my opinion.
For the solo music, I could go either way. Some of it does seem to sound a little better with the piano; I'm not a "purist", I don't need period instruments all the time, and sometimes I do prefer to hear his solo keyboard music on a piano rather than a harpsichord.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Classical Music Forum
2.6M posts
40.6K members
Since 2004
A forum community dedicated to classical music for musicians and other enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about composers, compositions, arrangements, collections, recordings, techniques, instruments, styles, reviews, classifieds, and more!