Likes: 
the Talk Classical Community's Favorite and Most Highly Recommend Works
The Talk Classical Community's
Favorite and Most Highly Recommend Works
Here is a prioritized list of classical music (inclusively defined) recommendations put together by members of the Talk Classical discussion forum and the (now defunct) Amazon.com classical music discussion forum.
Naturally, these recommendations represent the knowledge and tastes of the people who have helped build it. We do not claim that it is the official canon of art music, or that it is anything like an objective ranking of the greatness of each work!
However, to the best of our knowledge, nothing else like this exists -- no other list of prioritized recommendations including all genres of classical music, no other list as helpful to an old veteran looking for a surprise as to a newbie just familiarizing herself with the canon.
One interesting way to explore the list is this very-easy-to-use "Music Selector," created by a TC member who wishes to remain anonymous.
You can also view the list as a spreadsheet (though it may not be up-to-date), or as an unranked, alphabetical list. You can also see some simple statistical information here, which might help you estimate how prestigious each tier is.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Our project is ongoing, and we’d be very happy for you to add your own voice!
You can change our list in three ways:
1. The main way is to participate in the threads with titles like, "The first tier," "The second tier," and so on. You can find them in the polls sub-forum. Usually we have several going on at a time, but in order to avoid confusion, please don't bump the threads that have timed out!
2. The second way is to add new works to the list. If you want to recommend a work that is not already on our list, just post it in this thread. You can add up to 1 new work per day. All newly added works begin on the lowest tier, but they can move up from there.
3. Finally, you can move a work that you really love up rather quickly by creating a reference thread for it, such as this thread for Brahms's violin concerto.
To qualify, your thread has to:
- be on the main "Classical Music Discussion" board, or an appropriate sub-forum such as the opera board.
- link to the main list of recommendations like this: the Talk Classical community's favorite and most highly recommended works;
- link to the Wikipedia article about the work, if one exists;
- if Trout has compiled a summary of recording recommendations (Here is the list of works he's done, with links), link to his post about it and quote his "condensed listing";
- ask for comments about the work itself rather than just recommended recordings.
You can include almost anything else you'd like, such as requests for recommended recordings, analysis of the work, links to reviews or analysis, links to other TC threads about the work or its composer, links to the score on IMSLP, a link to the composer's thread in the guestbook sub-forum here, a youtube video of a performance or a lecture about the work (respecting copyright laws), and so on, as long as the focus remains on the work.
The second post of the thread will contain a template you can use.
The goal of the reference threads is to promote the works and help people who aren't already familiar with the works learn about and appreciate them.
By creating a reference thread, and posting a link to it in this thread (to be sure that I see your thread thread), you can move move a work to a higher tier. Creating a thread for a work on tiers 1-10 will move that work up 1 tier; a thread for a work on tiers 11-20 will move that work up 2 tiers; and so on. (If for some reason you don't want to move it up that many tiers, you can ask me to move it up fewer.)
You can only create 1 reference thread per day. Also, this can only be done one time for each work! Once a work has a reference thread, that's it!
One final way that you can contribute is simply by letting me know if you see errors in the list, such as incorrect dates, misspellings, and so on. You can do that in this thread, or if you prefer you can PM me.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
People might disagree with your votes, and you might disagree with theirs, but please be patient and persistent. Your participation will make our list better. We value everyone's participation.
If you are disappointed that a work you champion is not getting more community support, feel free to advocate for it, telling us why we should support it. Advocacy for a work will always be both more welcome and more productive than advocacy against a work.
Please be polite. Obviously we have different tastes and we don't all know the same things; we do not all agree about how strongly various works should be recommended, how great or important they are, or anything else.
The point is to learn from each other and help each other, to have a good time exploring music together.
Special thanks to Trout, who has maintained this list for years and years, and did a heck of a lot of work compiling recording recommendations, and to mmsbls, who has agreed to edit the posts in our thread when needed.
And thanks to all the people who have contributed in various ways to this project over the years! I personally have learned a lot from it, and I'm sure others have as well. I hope this will be helpful to people for many years to come, and I hope we continue to refine it as we all learn more about this amazing tradition.
Reply With Quote
Originally Posted by science
