Blog Comments

  1. eljr's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by haydnguy
    I was curious why you rated this 5/5 but did not recommend it?
    I did not recommend it because i do not believe it has mass appeal. I do recommend it for the few that can accept it's uniqueness.

    Sorry it took me so long to answer, I just found this question!
  2. haydnguy's Avatar
    I was curious why you rated this 5/5 but did not recommend it?
  3. Joe B's Avatar
    Thanks for the clarity. I appreciate the fact you took the time to explain it to me. It now gives me a deeper insight to your blog postings.
  4. eljr's Avatar

    i put those rating there for myself which is why they are but a number or number and letter

    it's code you cracked!

    i don't pretend to be a reviewer.

    i was gonna send you a pm to explain my simple, but for me, effective rating system

    i do not listen as most, i listen in macro, it's just natural to me

    the only element i rate is how it moves me, inspires me, demands my mood react to the sound

    virtuoso play, innovation, perfect clarity... it does not matter
    i ignore all this and instead demand the experience

    i don't think about or concern myself with which elements contributed to my reaction

    so, if someone asks me to compare two of the same works, I cannot

    I can only offer my sensory reaction, preference, without support.

    The numbers I assign are really a personal guide I use to recall the experience.

    a 3 1/2 or higher means I will look to listen to the piece again.

    a 2 1/2 or lower and I won't be listening again.

    Obviously a 3, means maybe.

    Then I put an R or don't after it.

    R is for recommend. An R means that I think, mistaken or not, that the recording would appeal to most even if I don't appreciate it. An example, the material may just not be what I enjoy but I fully recognize it's merit. That may get a 2.5R. I won't be listening again but if from the info I provide it interests you, I can recommend it.

    Conversely, I have rated things 4.5 and not recommended it. Why? It can be many reasons but in the end it comes down to me recognizing the recordings limitations yet it still appeals to my emotion, strongly in the case of a 4.5.

    I started adding the R when (on another form) people would be surprised at my rating and think a 3 not worth a purchase.
  5. Joe B's Avatar
    I was thinking about purchasing this material performed by Polyphony, but your giving this performance a 4R has me re-thinking.
  6. Joe B's Avatar
    Checked this out on I like the tune "Happieness Is...", it flows like any western song would. The others are very much like some native American flute music and Japanese shakuhachi music I have. Interesting.
  7. Joe B's Avatar
    I've got the 1983 release on CBS Records Masterworks of Yo Yo Ma playing:
    "The 6 Unaccompanied Cello Suites"
    "6 Suiten for Violoncello"
    "Les 6 Suites Pour Violoncelle Seul"
    Complete Works

    An excellent 2 CD set that was re-released by Sony in 2015
  8. eljr's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Joe B
    You can't go wrong having this in your music collection.
    This is the second performance of Mealor's Stabat Mater I own. I have my eye on a 3rd.

    Thanks again!
    Updated Aug-27-2017 at 13:22 by eljr
  9. Joe B's Avatar
    You can't go wrong having this in your music collection.
  10. Joe B's Avatar
    A great recording and performance.
  11. eljr's Avatar

    Fat Joe
    Me, Myself and I