Classical Music Forum banner

Ravel's double glissandi!

3K views 14 replies 7 participants last post by  PetrB 
#1 ·
Rectangle Font Line Slope Parallel


Well, I have been driven mad with this wretched section from Alborada del gracioso. The piece has not been as fiendishly difficult as I had anticipated (if you practice the repeated notes enough, they will come). But my fingers absolutely refuse to do the double glissandi-at this point, I am only half-skimming over them, and yet the pain is unbearable! I am doing the printed fingerings (but I don't think I like the 3-1 fingering coming down as the third finger's delicate side is the one coming down the keyboard).

Any hints? Fingering ideas? Words of wisdom? Encouraging Bible verses? :lol: I need something!
 
See less See more
1
#4 ·
The best advice I can give is to make a shallow angle. Fingers like they're about to lie down sideways on the keys. Reduces the feeling of impact on the sides of your fingers. Other than that..... .... have fun?

edit: this might be the kind of thing that youtube is helpful for -- you get good closeups of pianists' hands there, and you can see what other people do with this problem.
 
#5 ·
Thanks Heather...I practiced too much technique today and ran out of time for repertoire, but that really is a very helpful hint. I can in fact see Richter using a similar hand position here (despite his playing being a bit dry for my taste):

 
  • Like
Reactions: hreichgott
#12 ·
Thanks Heather...I practiced too much technique today and ran out of time for repertoire, but that really is a very helpful hint. I can in fact see Richter using a similar hand position here (despite his playing being a bit dry for my taste):
Another thing I notice about Richter's position is that he pretty much turns his hand palm up to play the glissandi. That would cause the hand's center of gravity to fall in the direction of the glissando, allowing the fingers to trail gently behind, instead of pressing into the keys as in normal playing. I could be wrong but it looks like he turns his hand so far that on the upward gliss the 2 plays the *higher* note and the 4 the lower note?
 
#9 ·
Hahaha...are you referring to that ghastly coverage of my concert on Shaw TV? The reporter was going off on all sorts of tangents, and eventually asked me to demonstrate a how a fugue works. So I did...I thought it was just for his curiosity but I guess he filmed it because it ended up in the clip! I thought it sounded really silly, but anyways...

And thank you for the compliment! :) I am from BC. Campbell River (Vancouver Island), to be precise. Are you also from BC?
 
#10 ·
Hahaha...are you referring to that ghastly coverage of my concert on Shaw TV? The reporter was going off on all sorts of tangents, and eventually asked me to demonstrate a how a fugue works. So I did...I thought it was just for his curiosity but I guess he filmed it because it ended up in the clip! I thought it sounded really silly, but anyways...
Hey, I want to see/hear your playing too!. Can you post a link to the video?.
 
#15 ·
A somewhat extreme axial wrist motion should place your thumb nail on the bottom third, the third (maybe 4th, maybe third and fourth together?) finger is then more on the flatter end of the fingertip. It will mean a very quick flick of the wrist, literally, the moment you've reached the apex and then descend.

Your thumb will be somewhat 'folded under' while the flat of the 3rd finger will be 'right there' for you (the plane of the back of your hand will be elevated outside right, and steeply inclined toward the thumb -- all without 'folding' of course :).

Points of contact for both thumb and third (or third & fourth, or whichever you decide) will be an a near parallel line on the left to right.

Of course if you are not used to it, like so many newer motions, you may at first feel you've lost whatever control you thought you had -- but anything but the flat of the upper finger is downright nasty, painful, and ineffective.

Break a leg.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top