Classical Music Forum banner
1 - 20 of 12055 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
380 Posts
He has told, that he uses "dubbing" in some of the pieces particularly in the trio sonata to overcome the technical difficulties.
Where did you read/hear that? I don't recall him mentioning it in the CD booklet (Rather disconcertingly, I can't find the CD--I listened to it via Qobuz yesterday), nor can I find any references to him overdubbing online.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
380 Posts
Having heard his Musicalisches Opfer it was clear to me, that he was using dubbing or had got assistance from another musician, so I discussed this with a friend, who decided to write to Lifschitz and ask about it. And in his answer he confirmed the dubbing.
Well, that is disappointing! I, too, initially suspected he might, but then after listening to a lot of Sorabji and insanely difficult orchestral transcriptions I was convinced that technique has improved to the point that the once seemingly impossible is now merely difficult. I guess he’s simply an ordinary virtuoso, not one of the current super-human players!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
380 Posts
I got a kick out of the label's PR release:

"When the red light in Studio 2 at the famous Abbey Road Studios came on at the start of the recording sessions for Elschenbroich’s and Grynyuk’s latest ONYX recording, the control room had a very different atmosphere. The recording was made using analogue technology – tape recorders, vintage microphones, and longer takes.At no point was the recorded material subjected to a digital process.

Elschenbroich wanted to capture a specific sound for these sonatas; the recorded sound of the late 1950s and the 1960s was his goal. The result is a wonderfully
intimate, warm yet clear sound, as if the musicians are actually in the room with the listener – not clinical, not a bright superficially impressive digital sound, but a
sound that captures perfectly the best recorded sound of the golden years of the LP. Importantly, it is the sound by which the artist ‘recognises’ himself. As Elschenbroich writes in the notes ‘ the listener only needs one pair of ears and the music must come to life in their unique space’."


So, why release it in digital-only formats?? To be sure, it's well played, the sound is rich and full, but also rather closely mic'd and dry. I'd definitely buy the LP if they ever release one, but in the meantime Qobuz's 24 bit 192kHz streaming will suffice.

Musical instrument Font Music Art Musical instrument accessory
 
1 - 20 of 12055 Posts
Top