No, I wouldn't say you're wrong at all. I don't personally hear it, but our ears have been known to deceive us.
No, I wouldn't say you're wrong at all. I don't personally hear it, but our ears have been known to deceive us.Well, I am definitely enjoying this 1st now, under Barbirolli's directing.
Am I completely wrong in saying that there seems to be some similarities in style between Buckner and Elgar? I love Bruckner.
I've been marvelling at the intensity of this Barbirolli recording. Just read an article where someone referred to it as "Barbirolli's operatic fury". Works for me.No, I wouldn't say you're wrong at all. I don't personally hear it, but our ears have been known to deceive us.
Barbirolli, along with Adrian Boult, were champions of Elgar's music. They did so much for this composer. His oeuvre is loaded with gems. In fact, your posting has inspired me to revisit the 1st, but I'll probably wait until tomorrow.I've been marvelling at the intensity of this Barbirolli recording. Just read an article where someone referred to it as "Barbirolli's operatic fury". Works for me.![]()
Apparently Barbirolli died a few days after the recording I'm listening to. That is stunning. To think someone could conduct like this with death knocking on the door...Barbirolli, along with Adrian Boult, were champions of Elgar's music. They did so much for this composer. His oeuvre is loaded with gems. In fact, your posting has inspired me to revisit the 1st, but I'll probably wait until tomorrow.
You're never wrong for what you hear. As I mentioned, I don't really hear a Bruckner influence, but I do hear Strauss who was a composer he greatly admired.And in the same article:
"Having had no musical education, Elgar drew his early inspirations from the German late-Romantic idiom, from Wagner, Bruckner and Richard Strauss, complemented by the contradicting otherness of Brahms. Deep down, he was a symphonist rooted in this tradition, and under a subtle but noticeable influence from Debussy, the French master of colour, he developed a highly individual orchestration technique to communicate the essence of his musical thoughts."
And from another piece:
"Elgar’s style drew on all the major influences of the day, while forging a highly personal and distinctly British style from them. His music was firmly rooted in the German Romanticism of Brahms and Bruckner and the programme visits lovely motets by these composers too."
So I guess I wasn't wrong in hearing the influence of Bruckner.
Well, Barbirolli was an "all or nothing" kind of conductor. He put his heart and soul into his performances and you can hear it. His Sibelius, for example, is absolutely stunning even if the sometimes scrappy playing from The Hallé makes some mistakes here and there. If you like Sibelius, do check out his recordings!Apparently Barbirolli died a few days after the recording I'm listening to. That is stunning. To think someone could conduct like this with death knocking on the door...
I listened to it in one day, but not one sitting.View attachment 181513
There is no way for me to listen to the whole thing (7 CDs, 8 1/2 hours) in one sitting. I'll do it next few days in piecemeal.
You are Da Man.. until we find someone who did it in one sitting 😎I listened to it in one day, but not one sitting.
Does it count that I saw Jonathan Powell play "Opus Clavicembalisticum" in concert with just one intermission?You are Da Man.. until we find someone who did it in one sitting 😎