This week I've been listening to more choral music from Robert Shaw:
1.
Berlioz:
Requiem (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus w/John Aler, tenor);
Bioto:
Prologue to Mefistofele (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus w/John Cheek, bass; the Morehouse-Spelman Chorus; the Young Singers of Callenwolde);
Verdi:
Te Deum (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus) 1985
2.
Faure:
Requiem (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus w/Judith Blegen, soprano; James Morris, bass);
Durufle:
Requiem (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus) 1987
3.
Hindemith:
Where Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd: A Requiem for Those We Loved (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus w/William Stone, baritone; Jan DeGaetani, mezzo-soprano) 1987
4.
Rachmaninoff:
Vespers/All-Night Vigil (Robert Shaw/Robert Shaw Festival Singers) 1990
5.
Orff:
Carmina Burana (Robert Shaw/Atlanta Symphony Orchestra & Chorus w/Judith Blegen, soprano; Haken Hagegard, baritone; William Brown, tenor & the Atlanta Boy Choir) 1981
Telarc Records
These are all great, quality recordings by Robert Shaw and friends. While Colin Davis' more restrained and reverent rendition of Berlioz'
Requiem that he made with the London Symphony Orchestra is my favorite, Shaw's is still very good; somewhere in between Davis' restraint and Leonard Bernstein's spectacular recording he made with the French National Orchestra. The added filler by Boito and Verdi is also very fine.
The two
Requiems by Faure and Durufle are appropriate companion pieces, both by French composers and evoking an air of ethereal beauty; very sweet and heavenly; and once again, Shaw and the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra and Chorus do well to hold there own and then some in a field of innumerable alternate versions by the best conductors, orchestras, and choruses the world over.
Next up, the lesser-known
Where Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd: A Requiem for Those We Loved
by Paul Hindemith, then living in the USA and composing it as a tribute to President Franklin D Roosevelt who died in 1945. For a composer who is known as a gnarly and austere German academic,
Where Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd could practically pass for a fairlt listenable piece of "Americana" by the likes of William Schuman or Walter Piston. Interestingly, Roger Sessions would publish yet another magnum opus based on the same epic poem by Walt Whitman with his own serial version of
Where Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd that was composed in honor of another fallen president, John F Kennedy, who was assassinated in 1963.
This is followed by Shaw's beautiful rendition of Rachmaninoff's
Vespers/All-Night Vigil, which is also very fine and beautiful even if it doesn't have the support of those very big and powerful bass voices that we get in other recordings featuring Russian, Baltic, and Eastern European choral groups.
We end with a lively and yet well-measured of Orff's medieval-inspired
Carmina Burana; a well-trodden warhorse, where Shaw and friends, again, do very well to hold their own.