Joined
·
16,602 Posts
I think Metzmacher conducts one or two symphonies on the Challenge set. I bought it a few years ago but I need to revisit as well.NP:
K. A. Hartmann
Symphony No. 6
Bavarian RSO
Kubelik
![]()
For me, this is still the set to beat. There's a spirit in the performances that can't be matched. The Metzmacher on EMI always seemed to be interpretatively uninteresting. Like he's getting the orchestra to play the notes, but that's it. There's no thrust or inner life in his performances. They're all faceless. I haven't done enough listening of the newer Challenge Classics set to make a direct comparison with the Wergo, but I should revisit that set.
I love that set.Mozart, Symphony No. 40
Well done, especially for a period-instrument ensemble. Pinnock doesn't sacrifice nuance for "authenticity."
View attachment 159373