I've never been a big Anner Bylsma fan. The few recordings of his that I have on hand, especially those with Frans Brüggen and Gustav Leonhardt, have never "moved" me in any particular way, rather seeming dull and lifeless. And I am a fan of Baroque music in general. Perhaps the artist's particular penchant towards "authentic" Baroque performance practices has proved off-putting for me. I really don't know. But I've come to think of Anner Bylsma as Anner Dismal, and perhaps all the blame resides with me.
Still ... following a reading of a thread on this website which concerned the Bach cello suites with an enthusiastic mention of the recordings by Bylsma, and upon realizing that I did not have those recordings on hand, I decided to break a long-standing practice of mine and to purchase the Bylsma Bach recordings.
I found both of his sets (the 1979 and the 1992 recordings) in a single box set titled
Anner Bylsma Collection: Cello Suites - Sonatas, featuring works by "Bach, Vivaldi, Boccherini and more". I bought it. Eleven CDs for $35 seemed reasonable to me.
I must say, I thoroughly enjoyed the Bach Cello Suites, preferring the later recordings (which struck me as "more thoughtful" -- highly recommended!) but realizing I could live with the earlier set were it the only one I had on hand. Still, it is good to have both in this one convenient package. That alone is worth the cash to me.
I did sample a couple of the other discs in the set. (The Bach solo cello suites take up 4 discs.) Of those I listened to (samplings from the Vivaldi and Boccherini discs), I was reminded of my previous unaffections for Bylsma. (I see that Brüggen and Leonhardt are also included on some of this box set's recordings.) But to have the Bylsma Bach Suites, especially the 1992 issue, makes the box worth its price.
Will I give up my
Zuill Bailey or János Starker or Hideki Suzuki or Jörg Metzger or Yo-Yo Ma sets for this one? No. But I do appreciate different artists' differing approaches to the music, and the Bylsma set(s) can certainly and proudly share the same shelf space as those others. Two more versions to choose from when next I get in the mood for the Bach Cello Suites -- that's a good thing.