Hummel, Field and Ries composed a bundle of them each.
Sounds interesting. I have some notes on early French composers of piano concertos and it will be good to compare.I recently heard the new album by Ronald Brautigam playing Johann Wilhelm Wilms and really liked it. So let's talk piano concertos from that time! I also like that the first movement is long as ever with so called type 5 sonata form![]()
I think I heard each of them at least once, and still listen to them occasionally while I do chores. If I were to pick one to recommend to anyone, it would be the D minor, Wq 22. While Wq. 6, 7, 15, 17, 23, 26 (and the ones transcribed as cello cocnertos), 34 (with its emphasis on the galant style), etc, are melodically memorable. The slow movements of Wq. 20, 27 moody harmonically. But these days I find Bach a bit too rhythmically static, especially in the 8-9 minute long concerto slow movements (compared to his elderly contemporary Richter (1709-1789)).Of course, CPE Bach is a very familiar name but I wonder how many of us are familiar with his keyboard concertos (BIS issued some 20 CDs of them) and nearly all are really worth getting to know. There is so much magic in them and we can also hear the transition from the Baroque to the Classical - some works have both feet in one of these "camps" but in others he seems to have one foot in each.
I listened to Hummel's Piano Concerto No. 2 and liked it! All except for the opening orchestral tutti that was unengaging. Once the piano had entered smoothly, all was well. No longer need I think of Hummel as a composer mainly to be brought in for thin areas of the repertoire -- such as septets.Just heard one by Hummel![]()
Interesting, the opening orchestral tutti is one of my absolute favourite opening tutti’s of any concerto. Maybe this recording will change your mind?I listened to Hummel's Piano Concerto No. 2 and liked it! All except for the opening orchestral tutti that was unengaging. Once the piano had entered smoothly, all was well. No longer need I think of Hummel as a composer mainly to be brought in for thin areas of the repertoire -- such as septets.