Joined
·
3,329 Posts
Agreed. For me the best approach is Jochum. Just beautiful.Fortunately, those aren't the only choices - there's a lot of territory between Gardiner's severn minutes and Klemperer's twelve.
Agreed. For me the best approach is Jochum. Just beautiful.Fortunately, those aren't the only choices - there's a lot of territory between Gardiner's severn minutes and Klemperer's twelve.
Yes - the Jochum is one of my favorite modern instrument versions. And believe it or not, Solti's version is also excellent.Agreed. For me the best approach is Jochum. Just beautiful.
A dance!!!!!!! ................noun: sarabande
a slow, stately Spanish dance in triple time.
You're misreading it. It's an urgent call. 'Come ye daughters.....'True. And considering the opening of the Matthew Passion is one choir encountering the other choir in an extreme stage of mourning, the relatively sprightly dance Gardiner whips up is kind of inappropriate. At least in my opinion.
Well, the full sentence is Come ye daughters and help me lament. They're not going to the disco; they're watching a man carrying his cross to be brutally killed. I mean, I think that's what Klemperer wants to bring out of it; it reflects the slow, halting steps of Christ carrying his cross and their realization that he is doing it for them ("Behold our guilt").You're misreading it. It's an urgent call. 'Come ye daughters.....'
Wow. As far as musical greats in one room, I think that beats that picture with Elvis with Jerry Lee and the rest of the Million Dollar Quartet.Wow. Anyone ever seen this 1929 picture?
Alright, who's the one in the middle between Toscanini and Klemperer? The rest I recognized instantly but I'm drawing a blank on him.Wow. Anyone ever seen this 1929 picture?
![]()
Sorry if it's off-topic.
Erich Kleiber?................Alright, who's the one in the middle between Toscanini and Klemperer? The rest I recognized instantly but I'm drawing a blank on him.
Damn, Klempy was a giant. Great pic.Wow. Anyone ever seen this 1929 picture?
![]()
Sorry if it's off-topic.
This is a quite well known picture...Eric Kleiber between AT and Klemp.Alright, who's the one in the middle between Toscanini and Klemperer? The rest I recognized instantly but I'm drawing a blank on him.
Thanks, I hadn't seen that photo before. Some titan's there!Wow. Anyone ever seen this 1929 picture?
![]()
Sorry if it's off-topic.