Classical Music Forum banner

Rate the Eras of Classical Music

9K views 71 replies 44 participants last post by  norman bates  
#1 ·
From favorite to least favorite:

Romantic/Impressionisitc
Classical
Baroque
Contemporary(Atonal)
 
#5 ·
I don't have a preference and listen to all in about equal measure. Almost every day I listen to some Bach/Couperin/Froberger/Rameau and then to some Schoenberg and Brahms and Schubert and Lutoslawski. I like the variety. I would get bored fast if I listened only to romantic for example, because if you listen too much to it, most of the symphonies start to sound pretty similar.
 
#15 ·
Impossible! Personally, I do not (yet) get or spend much time with pre-Baroque music. But, for then on, I can't think of an era (up to the present day) that is somehow better or worse than the others. I spend wonderful time with them all. I could not say whether any of Mozart, Beethoven, Bach or Brahms is better or greater than any of the others - not personally or "objectively" - and then in each era there are so many others who are as great. Riches abound.
 
#29 ·
This pretty much describes me. Except that I use 1919 as my cutoff date.

20th century up through, and including, contemporary are my favorite eras, and pretty much all I listen to.
 
G
#35 · (Edited)
I tend to be more aware of the decade rather than the era with most music I listen to

2010s
2000s
1980s
1950s
1960s
1970s
1990s
1910s
Late Romantic (post-Wagner) and Mid Romantic (particularly for Wagner's mature works)
1900s
Medieval
Baroque
Renaissance
1920s
Classical
1930s
1940s
Early Romantic
 
#36 · (Edited)
1. Romanticism

The best (Wagner, Bruckner, Chopin). (But also some of the worst)

2. Modernism

Most creative and productive period in classical music history but I don't think it produced any absolute geniuses like the Romantic era did. At least there are no pieces as profound as Bruckner's 9th, Mahler's 10th, Parsifal, etc. Stravinsky isn't even my favorite composer of this era but he comes closest to the definition of "genius."

3. Renaissance

Amazingly beautiful music. This period is very long and much more diverse than is often recognized. Everyone but deprofundis underrates Renaissance music :lol:

4. Baroque

10% Glory, 90% click-clack continuo. The Glory (several cantatas by Bach, mostly the Actus Tragicus, and his masses/passions/oratorios) is definitely worth it though

5. Classical

I love Mozart but not much else
 
#68 ·
I'm not sure that modern era hasn't produced any profound pieces

There's Stra vinskys Rite of Spring, which certainly is a very different type of profound.

Shostakovichs symphonies, particularly 5,7,10,14, and 15 I consider to be very profound.

Prokofiev Romeo and juliet and fifth symphony (also piano and violin concertos)

There's also plenty of ravel and Britten works that I would call profound. But I guess what matters what your definition is.
Dictionary defines it as "very great or intense." Still kind of vague...