[Revitalized Classics]

Just as a supplement, some early records have made their way onto Youtube such as Nellie Melba from 1910 and Suzanne Brohly, 1920. I rather enjoyed the version by Maria Jeritza from 1926.

If we stick with electric records, there are some interesting versions including Cernay and Tirard and also Anderson in a live broadcast.

Germaine Cernay, 1928

Charlotte Tirard, 1929

Marian Anderson, 1943

 

[Revitalized Classics]

In the end, I cast my vote for Sutherland.

I enjoy Callas' performance but I find there is a vulnerability and resignation to Sutherland's performance which I find more moving. Just occasionally, Callas' forceful, proactive artistry grates on me. The bitterness and scorn and doleful sound are epic, but I've found it a bit of a relief this past week when turning to Tebaldi in Traviata, Souliotis in Norma, Sutherland in this Le Cid.

 

[Revitalized Classics]

Sorry I wasn't able to use your marvelous soprano suggestions for round three.

Hello, no problem! I'm pleasantly surprised they've generated even a little discussion given the age of the recordings and several of the singers aren't well known. Thanks for the different rounds, I'm enjoying hearing the singers/reading the discussion. David