Classical Music Forum banner
1 - 20 of 37 Posts

·
Premium Member
Chicago (ex-Dublin)
Joined
·
4,100 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Font Rectangle Electric blue Symbol Logo


Welcome to "The Great Composers" - The Classical Era - Semi-Finals - Game 3 of 4

The decision to use the word "Great" rather than "Greatest" was intentional - We are attempting to express the perception of "greatness" within a multiplicity rather than identified and represented by an individual - The intended concept is an attempt to identify and judge those composers who have elevated craftmanship into timeless artistry.

The Format -

Five separate groups numbered 1 through 4, each of which contains 16 composers, competing in Semi-Final rounds with the top 5 from each - then advancing to a Final of 20 composers.


The Rules -

1.) You may vote once per calendar day.

2.) You have a total of 20 points to distribute per entry with a maximum of 5 per individual composer.

3.) Play will end with the first composer to reach 100 points.


4.) The next 4 highest totals will then move on to the Final



Note: You are welcome to comment upon any and all aspects of this competition provided such commentary is directed to this thread -


This particular thread is reserved exclusively for game play.

Allow me to once again welcome you, to thank you for your participation, and to wish your favored composers the very best of luck during the course of these competitions.

Game 3 of 4 -

William Herschel

Niccolò Jommelli

Leopold Koželuch

Joseph Martin Kraus

Franz Krommer

Friedrich Kuhlau

Andrea Luca Luchesi

Etienne Nicolas Mehul

Leopold Mozart

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart

Josef Mysliveček

Sigismund von Neukomm

George Onslow

Vaclav Pichl

Johann Peter Pixis

Joseph Ignaz Pleyel
 

·
Premium Member
Chicago (ex-Dublin)
Joined
·
4,100 Posts
Discussion Starter · #2 ·
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2 (+2)
Niccolò Jommelli - 2 (+2)
Leopold Koželuch - 2 (+2)
Joseph Martin Kraus - 2 (+2)

Franz Krommer - 0
Friedrich Kuhlau - 0
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 0
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 2 (+2)

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 4 (+4)
Josef Mysliveček - 3 (+3)
Sigismund von Neukomm - 0

George Onslow - 0
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 0
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 3 (+3)

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,381 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 2
Leopold Koželuch - 2
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7 (+5)

Franz Krommer - 0
Friedrich Kuhlau - 0
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 0
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 2

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 9 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 3
Sigismund von Neukomm - 0

George Onslow - 5 (+5)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 0
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 3

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Brahms, Schumann
Joined
·
17,545 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 2
Leopold Koželuch - 4 (+2)
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 2 (+2)
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5 (+5)
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 0
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 2

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 9
Josef Mysliveček - 5 (+2)
Sigismund von Neukomm - 2 (+2)

George Onslow - 10 (+5)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2 (+2)
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 3

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Super Moderator
I DON'T BELIEVE IT!
Joined
·
32,563 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 2
Leopold Koželuch - 9 (+5)
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 7 (+5)
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 0
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 2

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 9
Josef Mysliveček - 5
Sigismund von Neukomm - 7 (+5)

George Onslow - 10
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8 (+5)

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Brahms, Mozart, Sibelius
Joined
·
10,768 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 2
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 7
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 0
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 2

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 14 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 5
Sigismund von Neukomm - 7

George Onslow - 10
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,193 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 7 (+5)
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 7
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5 (+5)
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 2

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 14
Josef Mysliveček - 10 (+5)
Sigismund von Neukomm - 12 (+5)

George Onslow - 10
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaughnessy

·
Registered
Joined
·
171 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 7
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 7
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5 (+3)

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 19 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 12

George Onslow - 10
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
38,880 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12 (+5)
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 12 (+5)
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 24 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 12

George Onslow - 15 (+5)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,172 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 7

Franz Krommer - 12
Friedrich Kuhlau - 5
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 29 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 12

George Onslow - 15
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

Voting for the only guy I know, the market will then tell me which 4 others I should listen to
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,996 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 12 (+5)

Franz Krommer - 12
Friedrich Kuhlau - 8 (+3)
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 34 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 14 (+2)

George Onslow - 20 (+5)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
459 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 12

Franz Krommer - 12
Friedrich Kuhlau - 8
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 39 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 14

George Onslow - 20
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,333 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12
Leopold Koželuch - 9
Joseph Martin Kraus - 12

Franz Krommer - 15 (+3)
Friedrich Kuhlau - 10 (+2)
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 44 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 14

George Onslow - 20
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 8

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Super Moderator
I DON'T BELIEVE IT!
Joined
·
32,563 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12
Leopold Koželuch - 14 (+5)
Joseph Martin Kraus - 12

Franz Krommer - 20 (+5)
Friedrich Kuhlau - 10
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 5

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 44
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19 (+5)

George Onslow - 20
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 13 (+5)

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
171 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 12
Leopold Koželuch - 14
Joseph Martin Kraus - 12

Franz Krommer - 20
Friedrich Kuhlau - 10
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 8 (+3)

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 49 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 10
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19

George Onslow - 20
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 13

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
38,880 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 2
Niccolò Jommelli - 17 (+5)
Leopold Koželuch - 14
Joseph Martin Kraus - 12

Franz Krommer - 25 (+5)
Friedrich Kuhlau - 10
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 8

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 49
Josef Mysliveček - 15 (+5)
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19

George Onslow - 25 (+5)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 13

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,996 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 5 (+3)
Niccolò Jommelli - 17
Leopold Koželuch - 14
Joseph Martin Kraus - 17 (+5)

Franz Krommer - 25
Friedrich Kuhlau - 13 (+3)
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 8

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 54 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 15
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19

George Onslow - 28 (+3)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 14 (+1)

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Premium Member
Chicago (ex-Dublin)
Joined
·
4,100 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 5
Niccolò Jommelli - 20 (+3)
Leopold Koželuch - 14
Joseph Martin Kraus - 20 (+3)

Franz Krommer - 25
Friedrich Kuhlau - 15 (+2)
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 10 (+2)

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 55 (+1)
Josef Mysliveček - 19 (+4)
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19

George Onslow - 28
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 19 (+5)

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,381 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 5
Niccolò Jommelli - 20
Leopold Koželuch - 14
Joseph Martin Kraus - 25 (+5)

Franz Krommer - 25
Friedrich Kuhlau - 15
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Etienne Nicolas Mehul - 10

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 60 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 19
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19

George Onslow - 33 (+5)
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 19

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,500 Posts
20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer

William Herschel - 5
Niccolò Jommelli - 20
Leopold Koželuch - 19 (+5)
Joseph Martin Kraus - 30 (+5)

Franz Krommer - 25
Friedrich Kuhlau - 15
Andrea Luca Luchesi - 5
Étienne Nicolas Méhul - 10

Leopold Mozart - 0
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - 65 (+5)
Josef Mysliveček - 19
Sigismund von Neukomm - 19

George Onslow - 33
Vaclav Pichl - 0
Johann Peter Pixis - 2
Joseph Ignaz Pleyel - 24 (+5)

20 Points Max per Entry - 5 Points Max per Composer
 
1 - 20 of 37 Posts
Top