[kyjo]

Alwyn - Symphony no. 3 - 2 (+2)
Beethoven - Symphony no. 3 "Eroica" - 26
Berwald - Symphony no. 3 "Singulière" - 8 (+4)
Brahms - Symphony no. 3 - 22
Bruckner - Symphony no. 3 (original version) - 0

Enescu - Symphony no. 3 - 6 (+2)
Górecki - Symphony no. 3 "Of Sorrowful Songs" - 10
Jolivet - Symphony no. 3 - 8
Lutosławski - Symphony no. 3 - 2
Mahler - Symphony no. 3 - 16

Mendelssohn - Symphony no. 3 "Scottish" - 13
Nielsen, C. - Symphony no. 3 "Sinfonia Espansiva" - 4
Nørgård - Symphony no. 3 - 5
Rautavaara - Symphony no. 3 - 0
Saint-Saëns - Symphony no. 3 "Organ" - 12

Schmidt - Symphony no. 3 - 4
Sessions - Symphony no. 3 - 2
Sibelius - Symphony no. 3 - 10
Szymanowski - Symphony no. 3 "Song of the Night" - 6
Weinberg - Symphony no. 3 - 4 (+2)

 

[kyjo]

Beethoven - Symphony no. 3 "Eroica" - 50
Brahms - Symphony no. 3 - 38
Mahler - Symphony no. 3 - 36
Mendelssohn - Symphony no. 3 "Scottish" - 29
Górecki - Symphony no. 3 "Of Sorrowful Songs" - 18

Berwald - Symphony no. 3 "Singulière" - 20 (+4)
Saint-Saëns - Symphony no. 3 "Organ" - 22 (+2)
Nielsen, C. - Symphony no. 3 "Sinfonia Espansiva" - 14 (+2)
Sibelius - Symphony no. 3 - 14 (+2)
Szymanowski - Symphony no. 3 "Song of the Night" - 12
Nørgård - Symphony no. 3 - 11

Jolivet - Symphony no. 3 - 16
Weinberg - Symphony no. 3 - 10
Schmidt - Symphony no. 3 - 6
Enescu - Symphony no. 3 - 10

Lutosławski - Symphony no. 3 - 8
Sessions - Symphony no. 3 - 2
Alwyn - Symphony no. 3 - 2
Bruckner - Symphony no. 3 (original version) - 2
Rautavaara - Symphony no. 3 - 0

 

[kyjo]

Beethoven - Symphony no. 3 "Eroica" - 64
Brahms - Symphony no. 3 - 52
Mahler - Symphony no. 3 - 53
Mendelssohn - Symphony no. 3 "Scottish" - 37
Górecki - Symphony no. 3 "Of Sorrowful Songs" - 37

Berwald - Symphony no. 3 "Singulière" - 32 (+4)
Saint-Saëns - Symphony no. 3 "Organ" - 39 (+2)
Nielsen, C. - Symphony no. 3 "Sinfonia Espansiva" - 25 (+2)
Sibelius - Symphony no. 3 - 20 (+2)
Szymanowski - Symphony no. 3 "Song of the Night" - 23
Nørgård - Symphony no. 3 - 17

Jolivet - Symphony no. 3 - 24
Weinberg - Symphony no. 3 - 16
Schmidt - Symphony no. 3 - 6
Enescu - Symphony no. 3 - 10

Lutosławski - Symphony no. 3 - 16
Sessions - Symphony no. 3 - 2
Alwyn - Symphony no. 3 - 5
Bruckner - Symphony no. 3 (original version) - 2
Rautavaara - Symphony no. 3 - 0

 

[kyjo]

Great list of symphonies no. 3 in my opinion. The first six slots coincide with my six favorites, although I too would have placed Mahler ahead of Brahms. Berwald's Singulière doing so well was a nice surprise, as I quite enjoy that symphony. I only wish Tchaikovsky's, Dvorák's and Prokofiev's thirds were among the finalists, as they are excellent pieces of music in my view.

Agreed, I'm glad the Berwald is getting the recognition here that it so richly deserves. I think it's one of the most remarkable symphonies of the mid-19th century.