[science]

Our votes on the 129th tier, part 5 selected the following works...

To move up 2 to the 127th tier:
Myaskovsky: String Quartet #11 in E-flat, op. 67/2 "Reminiscences" [1945]
Obrecht: Beata es, Maria [1505]
Obrecht: Salve crux
Onslow: Wind Quintet in F, op. 81 [1850]
Penderecki: Kadisz [2009]
Pettersson: Symphony #9 [1970]
Philips: Cantiones Sacrae for 5 Voices [1612]
Power: Missa Alma redemptoris mater [15th century]
Prokofiev: Sonata for Two Violins in C, op. 56 [1932]
Rebel: Sonatas (12) in 2 or 3 parts (including Le Tombeau de M. de Lully) [1695]
Rheinberger: String Quintet [1874]

To move up 1 to the 128th tier:
Mompou: El Pont [1947]
Netzel: Cello Sonata in E minor, op. 66 [1899]
Nilsson: Nox Angustae [1967, 1972, 1978]
Nordgren: Symphony #8, op. 140 [2006]
Novák: Signorina Gioventu, op. 58 [1926-28]
Ohana: Si le jour paraît... [1963-4]
Ölander: String Sextet in D [c. 1850]
Onslow: String Quartet #21 in G minor, op. 46/3 [c. 1834]
Orff: Veni Creator Spiritus [1930]
Ornstein: Piano Concerto, SO 824 [c. 1921]
Paray: Mass for the 500th Anniversary of the Death of Joan of Arc [1931]
Perezzani: Primavera dell'anima [1990]
Persichetti: Parable IX for Band, op. 121 [1972]
Pijper: Wind Quintet [1928-9]
Pixis: Grand Sonata for Oboe and Piano, op. 35 [1823]
Pizzetti: Cello Concerto in C minor [1933-34]
Plummer: Anna mater matris Christi [15th century]
Poppe: Speicher [2008-2013]
Price: Symphony #1 in E minor [1932]
Ran: String Quartet #3, "Glitter, Doom, Shards, Memory" [2013]
Rangström: Symphony #2 in D minor "Mitt Land" [1919]
Rautavaara: Piano Concerto #2 [1989]
Reger: Sinfonietta, op. 90 [1904-1905]
Reicha: L'art de varier, op. 57 [1804]
Reinecke: Symphony #2 in C minor, op. 134 "Håkon Jarl" [1874]
Respighi: Piano Quintet in F minor [1902]
Reubke: Piano Sonata in B-flat minor [1857]
Rheinberger: The Star of Bethlehem, op. 164 [1891]
Riegger: Symphony #3, op. 42 [1946-7; rev. 1960]
Rihm: Sphäre um Sphäre for chamber ensemble [1992-2003]
Rochberg: Caprice Variations for violin [1970]

To remain on the 129th tier:
Moniuszko: Halka [c. 1847-8, rev. 1857]
Montsalvatge: Cinco Canciones Negras [1945]
Moroi: Symphony #3, op. 25 [1943-4]
Muldowney: Oboe Concerto [1992]
Nicolai: Symphony in D [1835/1845]
Niculescu: Ison II [1975]
Nielsen, S. H.: Ophelia Dances, concerto for accordion and sinfonietta [2012]
Nordheim: Warszawa [1968]
Nyman: The Kiss and Other Movements, including Water Dances [1985]
Orff: Trionfo di Afrodite [1953]
Panufnik, R.: Three Paths to Peace [2008]
Picker: Opera Without Words [2015]
Piston: Viola Concerto [1957]
Plau: Concerto for Tuba and Strings [1990]
Pohjola: Symphony #1 [2002]
Pousseur: Paraboles-mix [1972]
Punto: Horn Concerto #5 in F [1797]
Ran, Shulamit: Violin Concerto [2003]
Reznicek: Symphony #4 in F minor [1919]
Rihm: Die Eroberung von Mexico (The Conquest of Mexico) [1987-1991]
Rihm: Die Hamletmaschine [1983-1986]
Rihm: Dionysos [2009-2010]
Rihm: Fremde Szenen I-III, for piano trio [1982-1984]
Rihm: Jakob Lenz [1977-1978]

To move down 1 to the 130th tier:
Persichetti: Symphony #6 for Band, op. 69 [1956]

 

[science]

Berio: Mutazione for tape [1955]
Castiglioni: Attraverso lo specchio [1961]
Maderna: Ages [1972]
Maderna: Continuo [1958]
Maderna: Notturno [1956]

 

[science]

I have added these works:

Assandra: Duo Seraphim [1609]
Bach: Alles mit Gott und nichts ohn' ihn, BWV 1127 [1713]
Beethoven: Bagatelles (7), op. 33 [1801-02]
Beethoven: Bagatelles (11), op. 119 [1803-22]
Beethoven: Sextet in E-flat, op. 71 [1796]
Bergman: Flute Concerto, op. 89 "Birds in the Morning" [1979]
Berio: Mutazione for tape [1955]
Billone: Mani.Giacometti [2000]
Birtwistle: Clarinet Quintet [1980]
Brumel: Lamentations of Jeremiah
Busnois: Missa L'homme armé [1468]
Buxtehude: Nun freut euch, lieben Christen g'mein, BuxWV 210 [c. 1700]
Carrillo: Mass for Pope John XXIII [1960]
Castiglioni: Attraverso lo specchio [1961]
Cerha: String Quartet #3 [2001]
Clemens non Papa: Ecce quam bonum [1558]
Clemens non Papa: Magnificat octavi toni
Clemens non Papa: Missa Gaude lux Donatiane [1557]
Compère: Crux triumphans [1502]
Dench: Piano Sonata [2015-6]
Ferneyhough: String Trio [1995]
Finnissy: String Trio [1986]
Freitas Branco: Vathek [1913]
Gordon: Clouded Yellow [2010]
Halffter, C.: String Quartet #7 "Espacio de silencio" [2007]
Hämeenniemi: Clarinet Sonata [1984]
Handel: Recorder Sonata in F, HWV 369 [1712]
Haydn: Piano Sonata #50 in D, Hob. XVI/37 [1780]
Haubenstock-Ramati: Für Kandinsky [1987]
Hensel (Mendelssohn, Fanny): Piano Sonata in G minor [1843]
Holst: Ode to Death, op. 38 [1919]
Joplin: The Entertainer [1902]
Kaipainen: Horn Concerto, op. 61 [2000-1]
Kokkonen: String Quartet #3 [1976]
Lassus: Cantiones sacrae a 6 [1594]
Maderna: Ages [1972]
Maderna: Continuo [1958]
Maderna: Notturno [1956]
Massenet: Le Roi de Lahore [1876]
Meriläinen: String Quartet #2 "Kyma" [1979]
Mozart: Piano Sonata #9 in D, K. 311 [1777]
Nanino: Mass for 8 Voices
O'Regan: Fragments from a Gradual Process [2007]
Orrego-Salas: Sextet for Clarinet, Piano and String Quartet, op. 38 [1955]
Poleva: Messages for onesimpleman [2009]
Reinken: An Wasserflüssen Babylon [before 1700]
Reynolds: Whispers Out of Time [1988]
Salmenhaara: Symphony #2 [1963-6]
Schreker: Der Schatzgräber [1920]
Schütz: Magnificat anima mea [1665]
Schütz: Veni, Sancte Spiritus [1664]
Shymko: Double Concerto [2014]
Tarrodi: String Quartet No. 2 (Madardal) [2013]
Veress: String Trio [1954]
Victoria: Missa O Magnum Mysterium [1592]
Volodos: Concert Paraphrase on Mozart’s Turkish March [1997]
Willaert: O magnum mysterium [1545]
Wolf-Ferrari: La vedova scaltra [1931]
Wolpe: Quartet for Trumpet, Tenor Saxophone, Percussion and Piano [1950-4]

We now have 248 works on the bottom tier, a total of approximately 6500 works.

 

[science]

Does anyone remember how Holmboe's Four Symphonic Metamorphoses got on our list?

I might break that into the individual works.

 

[science]

Antheil: Violin Sonata #1 [1923]
Lupo: Fantasia a 4 #5 [c. 1600]
Lupo: Time, that Leads the Fatal Round [1607]
Weinberg: String Quartet #1 [1939]
Weinberg: Violin Sonata #1 [1964]

 

[science]

As it turns out, there is a limit to how much editing you can do, and I've reached my limit for the week, so I'll have to add the following works to the alphabetical list later:

Lupo: Fantasia a 4 #5 [c. 1600]
Lupo: Time, that Leads the Fatal Round [1607]

 

[mmsbls]

Crumb: A Haunted Landscape (1984)

 

[Highwayman]

Davidovsky: Synchronisms #6 [1970]
Druckman: Windows [1972]
Eechaute: String Quartet #1 in G minor [1933]
Eliasson: Symphony #3 for alto saxophone and orchestra "Sinfonia concertante" [1989]
Senfl: Im Maien [c. 1534]

 

[Highwayman]

Braunfels: Tag- und Nachtstücke, op. 44 [1934]
Cesti: La Dori [1657]
Coke: Piano Concerto #4 in C-sharp minor, op. 38 [1954]
Coke: Piano Concerto #5 in D minor, op. 57 [1947]
Coke: Piano Concerto #6 in C minor, op. 63 [1954]
Enna: Kleopatra [1894]
Gompper: Double Bass Concerto [2018]
Pixis: Piano concerto in C, op. 100 [1826]
Puumala: Anna Liisa [2008]
Rouse: Symphony #5 [2017]

I think these were not added to the list.

 

[science]

I think these were not added to the list.

Thank you so much. I really regret that because if I hadn't made that mistake I think those works could've been on the list when we did that tier.

I've added it to the main list but not to the alphabetical one. I'll do that when I get editing privileges again.

How did you find that?

 

[science]

I'll add all of these to the lists now:

Braunfels: Tag- und Nachtstücke, op. 44 [1934]
Cesti: La Dori [1657]
Coke: Piano Concerto #4 in C-sharp minor, op. 38 [1954]
Coke: Piano Concerto #5 in D minor, op. 57 [1947]
Coke: Piano Concerto #6 in C minor, op. 63 [1954]
Crumb: A Haunted Landscape [1984]
Davidovsky: Synchronisms #6 [1970]
Druckman: Windows [1972]
Eechaute: String Quartet #1 in G minor [1933]
Eliasson: Symphony #3 for alto saxophone and orchestra "Sinfonia concertante" [1989]
Enna: Kleopatra [1894]
Fedele: Syntax [2015]
Francesconi: Das Ding singt [2017]
Gompper: Double Bass Concerto [2018]
Huang Ruo: Dust in Time [2020]

From here on has not been added to the alphabetical list:

Liang, Lei: A thousand Mountains, a million Streams [2017]
Lobo: Missa Maria Magdalena [16th Century]
Lupo: Fantasia a 4 #5 [c. 1600]
Lupo: Time, that Leads the Fatal Round [1607]
Morales: Lamentabatur Iacob [16th Century]
Morales: O magnum Mysterium [16th Century]
Narvaez: Los Libros del Delphin [1538]
Pixis: Piano concerto in C, op. 100 [1826]
Puumala: Anna Liisa [2008]
Rouse: Symphony #5 [2017]
Senfl: Im Maien [c. 1534]
Tenney: Arbor Vitae [2006]
Vivanco: Missa in Manus tuas [1608]

 

[Highwayman]

How did you find that?

I searched for Braunfels on the main list and couldn`t find any works by him. I thought it`s a bit strange then I searched for him in this thread and voilà!

 

[mmsbls]

Lindberg: Violin Concerto No. 1 (2006)

 

[Waehnen]

This TC-Recommended Lists -thingie is overwhelming! So many threads on it. I should start the research to get the hang of it and maybe start contributing.

How many people have contributed to the lists? Is it truly an objective poll?

 

[Ludwig Schon]

Every time I see these tiers, I’m reminded of the circles of hell in Dante’s Inferno…

 

[science]

This TC-Recommended Lists -thingie is overwhelming! So many threads on it. I should start the research to get the hang of it and maybe start contributing.

How many people have contributed to the lists? Is it truly an objective poll?

I'm sure it's not objective (I'm not sure how a poll would be) and I can only guess at the number of people who have contributed. A conservative guess would be maybe 60 and a generous one would be maybe even more than 200.

The easiest way to contribute is to go to the polls sub-forum and find an active "tier" thread. I think there are three right now.

 

[science]

Every time I see these tiers, I’m reminded of the circles of hell in Dante’s Inferno…

Why not the spheres in his Paradiso?

 

[science]

Adams, John Luther: Lines Made by Walking [2019]

 

[science]

Our votes on the 11th tier selected the following works...

To move up 2 to the 9th tier:
Mendelssohn: Violin Concerto in E minor, op. 64 [1844]

To move up 1 to the 10th tier:
Bach: Musikalisches Opfer (A Musical Offering), BWV 1079 [1747]
Bach: Sonatas and Partitas for Solo Violin, BWV 1001-1006 [1720]
Brahms: Piano Concerto #1 in D minor, op. 15 [1858]
Mozart: Symphony #40 in G minor, K. 550 [1788]
Tchaikovsky: Violin Concerto in D, op. 35 [1878]
Vivaldi: Il cimento dell'armonia e dell'inventione, including Le quattro stagioni [1725]

To remain on the 11th tier:
Mahler: Symphony #1 in D "Titan" [1896]
Rachmaninoff: Piano Concerto #3 in D minor, op. 30 [1909]
Rimsky-Korsakov: Scheherazade, op. 35 [1888]
Sibelius: Symphony #2 in D, op. 43 [1902]

To move down 1 to the 12th tier:
Debussy: La Mer, L 109 [1905]

 

[science]

Added to both lists:
Adams, J. L.: Lines Made by Walking [2019]
Birtwistle: Harrison's Clocks [1998]
Dufourt: Erlkönig [2006]
Feldman: Palais de Mari [1986]
Greif: Sonate de Guerre [1975]
Morales: Lamentabatur Iacob [16th Century]
Morales: O magnum Mysterium [16th Century]
Narvaez: Los Libros del Delphin [1538]
Nørgård: Turn [1973]
Pixis: Piano concerto in C, op. 100 [1826]
Posadas: Erinnerungsspuren [2014-2015]
Puumala: Anna Liisa [2008]
Rouse: Symphony #5 [2017]
Rzewski: Main Yingele [1989]
Senfl: Im Maien [c. 1534]
Takemitsu: Rain Tree Sketch [1982]
Tenney: Arbor Vitae [2006]
Tuur: Piano Sonata [1985]

Added to the main list but not yet to the alphabetical list:

Liang, Lei: A thousand Mountains, a million Streams [2017]
Liang, Lei: Garden 8 [2004]
Lindberg: Violin Concerto #1 [2006]
Lobo: Missa Maria Magdalena [16th Century]
Lupo: Fantasia a 4 #5 [c. 1600]
Lupo: Time, that Leads the Fatal Round [1607]
Vivanco: Missa in Manus tuas [1608]
Vivier: Shiraz [1977]