Classical Music Forum banner

Opera Memes!

3 reading
34K views 164 replies 40 participants last post by  MAS  
#1 ·
I'll start with a few of mine :devil:

Image


Image
 
#3 ·
When people started using the word "meme," I didn't know what they were talking about. I looked up "meme" and felt reasonably au courant. Now I'm confused again. I don't know what this thread is about. Don't tell me. I can force myself to be au courant only so many times before I forget my own name.
 
#7 ·
Somebody should create a meme to express this concept. It should include one of the golden age singers Woodduck adores, I suggest Flagstad as Brunhilde coupled with an image from a regie staging of the Ring. The caption would be: "I don't know what this production is about. Don't tell me. I can force myself to be au courant only so many times before I forget my own name."

N.
 
#24 ·
Like, I would say a joke format is a meme (in the original sense). Knock Knock! Who's There? It's a fill in your punchline thing.

Distracted Boyfriend is just a joke format. The medium is Image Macro rather than text (spoken or written).

Personified traditional staging is disappointed by Robert Wilson because he is thinking of using scary clowns instead. We find this funny because we've seen Robert Wilson stagings. And because we have to laugh at clowns or they'll hurt us.

Of course it might make more sense if Robert Wilson was every known for anything other than odd, minimalist, ritualized stagings with characters in over-the-top makeup. But we also know fans of traditional staging don't much care about actual history and going to be disappointed afresh every time. So we can take our amusement there.

But deep logic is not the point of these memes, and not necessarily at all important to how they spread. It's not an essay, it's a joke. And there aren't that many jokes about Robert Wilson's production styles (or similar topics) so we take what we can get.

And of course if I end up seeing Robert Wilson's Turandot in Toronto in October I'll be thinking of Distracted Boyfriend the entire time.

 
#23 ·
A meme is still a meme if it dies immediately. Just like in biology a gene is still a gene if it isn't passed on.

Some of the ones showcased in this thread are in popular formats. I can't say how many variations I've seen on that stock photo image of the lady being upset at her plaid-shirted gentleman who is distracted by the passing lady in red (as seen here in a new variation by The Conte). This is a version of a well-accepted format, even if it is barely two years old and the original stock photo is not much over three years old.

And I think the internet use is quite related to what Dawkins meant, even "meme" in the internet sense represents a very specific example of the phenomenon. These image macros spread, combine, mutate, and compete against each other (effectively).

Sure, the new ones posted here may have a short life, but if someone found one particularly funny they may copy the image and share it via other social media outlets. And if the new people that see it like it, it could spread further. Where the meme is originally posted isn't what's important; the content is.